Northport BOE OKs Drug Sweeps

Board approves use of police narcotics-detecting dogs in school.

The Northport-East Northport Board of Education approved the use of Suffolk County Police narcotic detection dogs for drug sweeps of school lockers at Monday's BOE meeting. Trustee David Badanes voted against the program.

The sweeps would be requested by the district, then scheduled on a day agreed upon by the Suffolk County Police and the district. Non-targeted sweeps would be conducted on lockers for 40 minutes while students are in their classrooms. If the dog “indicates” to a locker, the locker would be searched, and a uniformed Second Precinct police officer would be responsible for any contraband seized. School officials would be required to provide the police with the name, date of birth, and address of the student, and the police could effect a summary arrest.

A canine sniff of property is not considered a search under the Fourth Amendment because it is a non-targeted and random sweep. The dogs can detect illegal narcotic substances such as marijuana, heroin, and cocaine, but cannot detect legal controlled substances like prescription pills.

In order to implement the program, Suffolk Police require the district to notify parents and students that the school owns all lockers and locks and that students have no expectation of privacy for the contents within. The district would not need specific consent from parents to conduct the sweeps.

Language in the high school handbook saying that reasonable suspicion is required before a locker search would need to be amended to implement the drug sweep program. “Whether or not you move in the direction of dogs, we need to take a look at this, particularly at the high school,” advised Board Counsel John Gross.

Providing the handbook is changed and parents are notified, the sweeps are legally permissible, advised Gross, but could open the board to potential lawsuits. “We're talking about trial, depositions...it would be an expensive proposition” he said, adding that, in certain situations, insurance may not cover monetary damages and fees.

Use of drug sniffing dogs is not prevalent in New York, said Gross, due to a dearth of case law on its constitutionality. “Drug sniffing dog utilization is more prevalent in the south and west because those circuit courts tend to be more conservative,” he said.

Trustee Joe Sabia, who first proposed the program to the Board last summer, said that drug abuse among students is a more pressing concern than any potential law suit. “Anything that we can do as a community to stop drug abuse is a feather in our hat,” he said.

Trustee Badanes objected that the program is flawed. In a Nov. 5 letter to the board he wrote that random drug sweeps are a violation of a students privacy, liberty, and constitutional rights, would open the district up to law suits, and are not proven to be an effective deterrent. His letter is attached as a PDF.

Earlier this year, the Northport-East Northport Drug and Alcohol Task Force formed a subcommittee to evaluate the proposal and present their findings to the board. Their decision was split.

Anthony Ferrandino, co-chair of the Task Force and Northport High School drug and alcohol counselor, said he welcomes the program and sees it as "another layer of intervention." Task Force member Rob Ingraham said he opposes the program because there is no evidence of its efficacy in preventing drug possession or abuse, it will open the school to law suits, and may errode the relationship of trust between students and teacher.

One parent who spoke at the board said she is overwhelmingly in favor of the sweeps and said any measure taken to prevent drug abuse among students is justified. High School Principal Irene McLaughlin said she thinks it will serve as an effective deterrent on school property.

Board Vice President Jennifer Thompson said she's glad that the board has taken time to mull the proposal. “I feel more comfortable moving forward...there are an overwhelming number of students that we have gone to funerals for," she said.

In July 2011, the Drug and Alcohol Task Force presented the 2010-2011 NYS Youth Development Survey to Board members. Among the findings: parental attitudes towards alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs are above state norms in grades 9-12. A PDF of the full report is attached to this article.

DogPatch November 27, 2012 at 02:24 AM
whatever the legality - I don't like the notion of my kids or anyone's kids being subjected to police action if there isn't some suspicion behind it. Best they don't even see it happening. NYPD stop & frisk stats say they search 600,000 people, and only 1% of them had weapons. However, the other 99% of those searched are likely to resent the police for doing it, and trust them less. That doesn't seem very efficient or effective. Does anyone have any statistics on actual drug incidents in Northport Schools? I'm a little offended by some of the comments here - as I'm worried about the effect on the innocent kids being exposed to this... and from what I understand binge drinking is the biggest threat & I don't see how this will help at all.
DogPatch November 27, 2012 at 02:36 AM
this thread has me reading too many statistics on drug & alcohol abuse. If you really think your kids are exempt - then you are exhibiting the exact parental behavior that allows this problem to go on unchecked. What BOE member thinks that NHS should be a haven for drug use? I'd also like to see who in the district is "accepting of illegal drugs". Your comments are offensive, and a bit asinine. Trust me, the rest of us don't want our kids anywhere near yours either, because with a parent like you ... I'll stop there. But - if ANY kid - including yours - gets involved with drugs - then I pray they have someone to go to for help getting away from it (not away with it).
DogPatch November 27, 2012 at 02:50 AM
Chris posted - "My biggest problem with this discussion is the push for children to be granted knowledge that is traditionally reserved for adults." What knowledge is that? Sounds to me that like many parents your kids are thinking "what mom & dad don't know about won't hurt them". Caffeine. Nicotine. Alcohol. Kids learn to abuse these at home, from their parents. Ignorance is bliss. And if you're successful in blinding them to all this is HS, when they go to college, they'll be the problem kids most in danger of dying of alcohol poisoning.
ray January 23, 2013 at 06:50 AM
Pills are really the big problem. My brother and I both had a pot head phase in high school and we both graduated top 15 in our class. We were smart, worked hard and got good grades. I know a TON of people that smoked weed in high school and are doing just fine. It is up to the person to be responsible. Pills on the other hand ruin kids. I've seen way to many kids become pill heads (xanax, vicodin percs oc's roxys) and completely lose their way. Then after high school when they are going nowhere from all the pills they did in high school they start doing it even more eventually some move to heroin. And then some OD. That is the real problem and tragedy. Drug sniffing dogs will not find pills so it is pointless. If we are adults we should realize marijuana is not even that harmful pretty much everyone eventually at least tries it in college these days. NO joke.
ray January 23, 2013 at 07:09 AM
And Furthermore, this is promoting the use of prescription pills over marijuana because kids will not want to get caught by the dogs. Kids are going to do what they want to do. They will find ways around it. Let me tell you how kids think. 'Damn I can't sell weed in school anymore, I should start selling pills'. 'Damn I can't buy weed in school anymore maybe I should buy some pills'. Pills are the problem that needs to be attacked, I have seen firsthand how bad it is. And by the way it is also a lot of the rich parents faults for giving their kids money that a lot will end up spending on drugs.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »