.
Feedback

Filmmaker Reflects on Psych Center Tear Down

'It feels like it is being erased', said Kings Park movie documentarian.

 

Heavy machinery dug into the first of 19 buildings to be torn down during the first phase of demolition at the former Kings Park Psychiatric Hospital Monday, leaving a former patient turned filmmaker, wondering if enough is being done to commemorate what has happened there.

Lucy Winer was one of a dozen or so people who came out to witness the first official tearing down of one of the many buildings still standing on the property. Just a few days before it all began, Patch spoke with her as she shared her feelings on what was happening.

“What surprised me the most, if I had thought about it, I thought I would be quite happy, but that is not my reaction at all,” said Winer.

Winer was admitted to KPPC in 1967 at the age of 17 after a series of failed suicide attempts. Thirty years later Winer created the film, which documented her time at the hospital and takes a look at the state of mental health care today.

"From a community standpoint, I think it is great that efforts are being made to make the property more useful," said Winer. "But what disturbs me is that nothing significant is being done to commemorate or educate about what happened there and I think the history warrants that. It is almost like it is being erased."

Winer wrote a letter, published in Sunday's New York Times. Instead of the joy she thought she might feel watching the first structure crumble, she said she feels grief, concerned that people with mental illness still do not get the help that they need.

"I fear that if we fail to learn from the past, we will go on to repeat many of the same mistakes," said Winer in her letter.

How do you feel? Do you share some of Winer's sentiments?

_________________________________________________________________

Let Patch save you time. Get great local stories like this delivered right to your inbox or smartphone everyday with our free newsletter. Simple, fast sign-up here.

Frank Mercuri August 15, 2012 at 12:36 am
I think Ms Winner has mixed emotion regarding the "home " she lived at for many years. however, all is not forgotten. There are numerous photos, including he film she produced, and writings that describe the center for what it was and did. There will be constant reminders from the varieous building that will remain and presently in use. There will be a future for the grounds , now a park, which will add to the vistors' inquisiveness regarding the past. All is not lost. As a resident of KP for 47 years I too have memories of those who worked there such as my son and daughter-in-law during their high school days to earn some extra money. many high School students worked there and their memories are surly filled with their experiences there, some that were told were sad some humorous. The Kings Park heritage museum and the adminstration center of the park have archives of information for the future generations to review. The transformation of a Phychiatric center to a park is a transition that only changes the reason for being there. Things of the past are not forgotten but one must also look to the future and the progress made to help those in need in a manner far different to some of the past techniques. We pray for those who are resting on the frounds and those who left for a better life and those who will continue to fight to keep the area a park for future generations to enjoy.
Frank Mercuri August 15, 2012 at 11:21 am
Pardon the name misspell "Ms Winer " , my apologies.
Anne Salazar August 15, 2012 at 04:04 pm
here is a great video produced by my friend about the place
http://youtu.be/HmMscH3Z2Kc
KPLifer August 15, 2012 at 07:27 pm
The museum website is down !! What a shame that such a great resource that belongs to the residents of KP is being uses as a pawn.
Barbara August 16, 2012 at 12:57 am
would love to see the documentary - will it be playing again locally at a theatre?
Nana Kathie August 19, 2012 at 12:42 am
I haven't thought of Kings Park in many years. My grandmother died there at the age of 92 in 1967. She was in a large ward for women who were senile. As a teenager, I thought the place was old and scary. I will look for the museum website.
NYB August 19, 2012 at 04:38 pm
Most of these places were shut down in the early 90's and patients were turned to the streets, the buildings boarded up and posted with security. Some of the facilities and architecture were rather interesting but it seems that at every turn .gov is interested in selling the properties and wiping them off the map while reserving access for those who can pay (medium to large budget films and prominent TV shows). It's all about the $$$.
Anonymous-family still reside in KP August 19, 2012 at 08:58 pm
As a teen, I worked at KPPC in food service. Even then I felt that it was a shame knowing that some of the patients there were seemingly forgotten by their friends and family. I empathize with Ms Winer--many of the mentally ill do not receive treatment. Neither the mentally ill person nor their family can bear the stigma and lonliness associated with being "branded". I was never able to have friends to my house as did my peers for fear that my mother would lose control over her emotions and/or behavior. After many years she received court ordered treatment due to an outburst wherein she threatened to kill a neighbor that my mother always swore was going to steal the "millions of dollars that I was worth." (My parents are strictly middle class.) The judge made it clear to my mother that she had to stay out of trouble for one year or face more serious charges. Mom did as she was told but on Day 366 she went directly to her therapist to say that she was discontinuing the medications and would not be returnng for any further appointments. Since that day, life at my parents' house has been hell. The family has fallen apart--she is not allowed any contact with her grandchildren as they have become frightened of her. The changes in her personality(ies) occurs much too quickly for them to comprehend. What we used to explain as "Grandma's invisible friend" has become much more.
Jennifer Sloat (Editor) August 20, 2012 at 01:21 am
To find out more about Lucy's movie and upcoming screenings, visit her Facebook page. https://www.facebook.com/kingsparkmovie
Barbara August 21, 2012 at 02:15 pm
I have missed the opportunities to see this film - how can I find out if it will be showing again?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Kings Park Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something